MY HANDS OPEN.
My dad forgot the knife for my mom to cut her santol. But at least he remembered the speaker.
This is how our family packs for the beach — with the entire contents of the kitchen and exactly one missing thing. We grilled burgers and ribs beside the nipa hut, the smoke rising into a sky that was sunny and breezy and still, somehow, completely humid. The sea was calmer than usual, more blue than I'd seen it in a while. My parents went swimming. My uncle settled onto the bench with his oil pastels and started to sketch. My cousin and I talked in the shade.
At some point I asked her: do you know how Granny Jo and Papang met?
She had just read "I'll Ask in Heaven" — my essay about the grandparents I never really knew, the one where I imagined them all into the same room and let myself wonder. She came to my question already holding it, already inside that tenderness. And she didn't know. She thought for a moment, genuinely trying, and then shook her head. I asked my uncle, who looked up from his sketching. He offered what he could — something about the Death March, about Pampanga, about a history so large it had swallowed the smaller story inside it. But the beginning, the actual beginning, the moment before everything — that he wasn't sure about either.
They crossed paths, was the closest anyone could give me.
I sat with that for a moment, listening to five different remixes of the same song my dad had put on the speaker, watching the blue water, thinking about how strange it is to come from people whose origins you can't quite locate. The whole story is there — decades of marriage, eggs on toast in the afternoon, a collar pressed carefully before a formal event — and yet the first sentence is missing. Just: they crossed paths. In Pampanga. During a war.
Maybe that's enough. Maybe it was always going to be enough.
The year was somewhere in the 1950s, and my grandmother Rosario was selling tickets at a dance social.
The way it worked: you bought a ticket, you got a dance. She was selling tickets, fair-skinned and quiet, the kind of woman whose love you felt more than heard. And then my grandfather Constancio came up to her. Tall, deeply tan, a man who moved through a room like he already knew where the music was going. He bought a ticket. And then another. And then every single one she had left.
He wanted her to dance with him the entire night.
I've seen him only in photographs — Papa Tony passed away long before I was born — but my dad is a carbon copy of him, truly, so in a way I know his face better than I should. That grin. The easy confidence of a man who loved boogie and swing, who felt a good song in his whole body and didn't think twice about it. I imagine him at that dance social not performing the gesture but simply — decided. The way some people are. He saw her and he was done looking.
They built a life in Caloocan. Seven children. Papa Tony managing security, Grandma keeping the home. She knew how to cook, how to bake, how to sew, how to crochet — the quiet industry of a woman whose love lived in her hands. They spoke Tagalog to each other. I don't know what their ordinary evenings looked like but I know the shape of them, because I grew up with her. By the time I knew her she moved slowly, her bones more visible beneath her skin, her words few. There was a language between us we couldn't quite cross. But she showed up — on the hour-long bus from San Mateo, stopping at the grocery store on the way. The baby blankets she sewed before my sister and I were even born. The birthday cards that always arrived. A love that didn't wait to be asked.
In 1979 she and Papa Tony emigrated to California with my dad and three of his sisters. A new country, a new life, everything they'd built carried across an ocean.
One year later, Papa Tony had a heart attack and died.
I don't know how to write that without just writing it plainly, because there is no softening it. He bought every ticket so he could dance with her all night, and then life gave her thirty years without him. She stayed in California. She helped each of her children raise their children. My dad still makes her recipes the way she taught him, and now when he puts a dish on the table that tastes like hers, that's when he talks about her. Not in long stories. Just: this was hers. A flavor that travels one generation further than you expect.
She passed in 2010. Thirty years a widow, still showing up for everyone.
I think about the girl selling tickets sometimes. How she couldn't have known. How the grandest beginning — a man so certain he bought out every dance just to be near her — didn't come with any promise about what came next. It never does. The gesture was real and the love was real and life was still cruel in the way that life sometimes is, indifferent to how good a story it's interrupting.
But she carried it. All of it. For thirty years she carried it forward and kept going.
That's something too. That's actually everything.
My dad visited the Philippines in the early nineties and saw my mom.
That's the whole origin story.
He saw her — black curly hair permed to her shoulders, no glasses yet — and that was it for him. My mom tells this story with a booming laugh, the kind that fills a room. There's a millisecond of silence first, just enough to let the extravagance land, and then she's laughing at the sheer drama of it. From the moment he laid eyes on me, she says, still a little astonished, still a little proud. He fell in love. He was so sure.
I believe her. I've met my dad.
They decided to be together and then spent a year on opposite sides of the world. Manila to San Francisco. This was the early nineties, the analog era, before the digital age flattened distance into something almost manageable. So they wrote letters.
My mom's letters were long, handwritten in her neat pointy cursive, full of heartfelt words. My dad sent cards — the kind you bought at stationery shops back when that was still a thing people did, when choosing a card for someone was its own small act of love. Inside each one he wrote a short message and signed off on the back of a Fujifilm photo, his big messy cursive identifying her only as D. Her name is Carina Heidi. He took the second half.
He sent her one every day.
Every single day, for a year, a card or a letter or a photo made its way from San Francisco to a house in Manila. The local mailman apparently got used to it — this daily stop, this reliable delivery, this one address that always had something waiting. I think about him sometimes, that mailman, working my dad's certainty into his route without knowing anything about it.
My dad didn't buy every ticket at a dance social the way his father did. He found his own version. Three hundred and sixty five small gestures that only add up to something enormous when you see them whole.
Nobody remembers how Dioscoro and Josefa met.
Papang was a colonel in the Philippine Army. In his early days of service, he was stationed at what was then Fort Stotsenburg — later Clark Air Base — in Pampanga, serving alongside US Army troops. Granny Jo's family lived at Fort McKinley, also in Pampanga. At some point before 1944 — before the Death March, before the war swallowed everything into history — they must have crossed paths. That's the whole story. That's all anyone has left of their beginning.
I try to picture them young and find I can't quite do it. I only ever knew them as my grandparents — both tan, both dark-haired, both thin, the kind of people who dressed up formally for Papang's military events and carried themselves with a quiet dignity. Somewhere inside those people were two younger versions who found each other in wartime Pampanga, in the middle of a world that was falling apart, and decided to stay.
By 1944 they were already married. And then the Death March happened.
Papang marched alongside my great-grandfather, the two of them among the tens of thousands of Filipino and American soldiers forced to walk from Bataan to Capas, Tarlac — over a hundred kilometers, under conditions that killed thousands. He survived. He came home to her. I don't know what that homecoming looked like, what was said or not said, whether they held each other for a long time or whether they were both too tired and too relieved for anything more than presence. I just know he came back and they kept going.
That's the origin story. Wartime. A military base. Crossed paths that nobody thought to document because the world was too loud and too dangerous for origin stories. What got documented was everything after — the long marriage, the life they built, the specific tenderness of two people who had survived something enormous together and chose, every day afterward, to be gentle with each other.
I wrote about them once before, in an essay where I imagined all four of my grandparents in the same room. I gave them back to each other in prose because I couldn't do it any other way. Papang bringing Granny Jo eggs on toast before heading out to play mahjong. Granny Jo in the afternoon with her crochet. The word pangga — my love — passing between them like something that had never needed explaining.
That's what I know of their love story. Not the beginning. Just the shape of it, worn smooth by decades of use.
And I've been thinking, sitting here at this beach with the question still unanswered, that maybe that's the most honest version of what love looks like anyway. Not the grand gesture or the certain gaze across a room. Just two people who crossed paths somewhere in Pampanga during a war, and then spent the rest of their lives showing up for each other in small, faithful ways, until showing up was the whole story.
They crossed paths. And then everything that came after was the love.
The sea was still blue when I stopped asking questions.
My uncle had gone back to his oil pastels. My parents had come in from the water. My dad was probably on his fourth remix of the same song. And I was sitting with what I'd found, which wasn't the origin stories I came looking for but something else — something quieter and maybe more useful.
I come from people who loved in grand gestures. Who loved in daily letters and Fujifilm photos and a nickname taken from the second half of a name. Who loved across a death march and a long marriage and thirty years of widowhood and a life built entirely from showing up. None of them knew, at the beginning, how the story would go. The girl selling tickets didn't know. The man who fell in love at first sight didn't know. The two people who crossed paths in Pampanga during a war didn't know. They just began. And then love was everything that happened next.
I used to think I was looking for proof. Some confirmation, borrowed from the people I come from, that the thing I'm hoping for is real. That it exists. That I didn't make it up. And I think I found that today — not in any single story but in all of them together, in the sheer fact that these people, whose blood I carry, loved and were loved and kept going.
But I also found something I wasn't expecting. Knowing how they found each other doesn't tell me how I will. Knowing the shape of their beginnings doesn't predict mine. And sitting here with the water calm and the music playing and the question still technically unanswered, I found that I didn't mind. I don't want to ruin the surprise of it. I don't want to arrive at my own beginning already holding a template.
The world is wide. There are so many possibilities I haven't thought of yet.
So I imagine my hands open. Not at peace exactly — I'm still human, still hoping, still aware of the waiting — but not clutching either. Not attached to a particular origin story or a certain kind of gesture or a moment that announces itself in a way I'd recognize. Just open. Willing to be found. Willing to follow the path wherever love is leading, to receive whatever life wants to give.
They crossed paths in Pampanga during a war and spent decades being gentle with each other.
My dad sent three hundred and sixty five letters and even if my mom doesn't have them anymore, he never really stopped writing. The way he shows up for her every day — that's the letter he keeps sending.
My grandfather bought every ticket so he could dance with her all night.
Maybe mine will look nothing like any of that. Maybe it will look like all of it at once. Maybe I won't know what it is until I'm already inside it, already halfway through the after, already becoming the story that someone will tell one day at a beach, not quite remembering how it began.
That's enough. That's actually everything.